5/13/11

American Idol Top 3

Okay. I know I said I wouldn't talk about American Idol on Jay Swag once Pia Toscano was unfairly eliminated, but this is just too big not to discuss with you guys! What do you think about this years top 3? Personally, I cannot believe that Scotty McCreery is in the final 3. I think out of all the contestants he has been one of my least favorites. I understand that he has a great tone for country music, but where is the range? You can't rely solely on your tone. For example, if he makes it into the top 2, how is he going to be able to sing the winners song? Most of the time the song written is a very big and powerful one. Scott simply doesn't have the vocal ability to do any big song justice. Next, we have Haley Reinhart, who probably has the best melodic sensibility of the three. She also has a great and unique tone but, unlike Scotty, she has the range to back it up. Her performances of "House of the Rising Sun," and "I Who Have Nothing" were two of the best performances in the whole competition. Now, with that all being said, I do not think that she will win the competition either. I think Lauren Alaina is going to win it all. She's the sweet teenager that America loves, with a powerful and pure voice. Also, she would do excellent singing a big powerhouse song for the finale. She's just the thing that most of America would like to so see win. Which ever way it goes is fine with me, as long as Scotty is not the winner. What are your thoughts?
-Jay P-

4 comments:

Erin said...

i personally love scott. he's so cuteee. but i think that Haley or Lauren should in it all.

Rachel said...

i want Lauren to win. She's so pretty and seems really sincere. but I think they are all very talented

Anonymous said...

LOVE SCOTTY <333

SMcCreeryFans said...

scottys gonna win it allllll. one of the best singers to ever be on the show